Houdah Software Forum Archive

Can't process Aperture Library

Member #1312
I've just bought Houdah Geo and expected to use it to process my Aperture library.
I can't select it (grayed).

Though the other sources (Photo library, Files and folders) work ok.

The library exists and can be opened by Aperture, and is functional.

Am I missing something ?
Houdah Software
Is there a yellow warning sign next to the library in HoudahGeo?

can you click the warning sign or the entry in the list of libraries?
Member #1312 original poster
No, nothing. No warning sign.
Member #1312 original poster
my configuration : Big Sur 11.2.2, iMac 2019, Aperture library imported from another Mac
Member #1312 original poster

To be more precise : the aperture library is grayed when I try to open it using the "add..." feature.

Otherwise, it simply is not present in the Libraries section. I don't see it; as if Houdah Geo did not recognize it.

Houdah Software
You cannot open an Aperture library as a file. You need to go through the media browser in HoudahGeo.

For the media browser to load the Aperture library:
  • You need to have Aperture installed
  • The Aperture preferences need to list your library as last used library
That should not be a problem if you installed Big Sur as an upgrade over a system that previously ran Aperture.

On a fresh install of Big Sur, you will face the problem that you cannot run Aperture. You can try putting the library at the same path as it was on your previous Mac and copy over the Aperture preferences file. This should allow HoudahGeo to find the library.

Do you want HoudahGeo to update the Aperture library? For that to work, Aperture needs to be running. 

You may want to try https://github.com/cormiertyshawn895/Retroactive to actually run Aperture on Big Sur. I cannot comment on the reliability of Retroactive for not having used it yet.

Member #1312 original poster
>For the media browser to load the Aperture library:
>You need to have Aperture installed
Check
>The Aperture preferences need to list your library as last used library
It should be good as it is the last used library and Aperture can re-open it.
I just checked, there's a 
com.apple.Aperture3.plist file,

which contains this:

<key>RecentLibraries</key>

<array>

<string>/Users/myname/Photos/Aperture Library.aplibrary</string>

</array>

[I've changed in the Finder the path, since there may have been a problem with the former name Photothèque/Aperture Library.aplibrary , because of the è  but with no result for Houdah Geo]  

>That should not be a problem if you installed Big Sur as an upgrade over a system that previously ran Aperture.
The system previously ran Aperture under Catalina, but I believe I had to re-patch Aperture by Revolut when Big Sur came in. 

>On a fresh install of Big Sur, you will face the problem that you cannot run Aperture.
Yes, except with Revolut, with some shortcomings.
 
>You can try putting the library at the same path as it was on your previous Mac and copy over the Aperture preferences file. This should allow HoudahGeo to find the library.
Not sure what you recommend here. Putting the Aperture library on the same path is not possible as it was on a different machine , with different structures and hard disks, and the files have been copied too.

Now that the Aperture preference file is clean, should I trash Houdah Geo to re-start from zero ?
Houdah Software
No need to reinstall HoudahGeo. Just quit and relaunch 

do you have Aperture.app in your Applications folder?
Member #1312 original poster
I've done that multiple times. Yes Aperture is in my app folder.
Maybe a privilege problem regarding Houdah geo ?
Member #1312 original poster
I have given access to all my disk to Houdah Geo, I have moved an aperture library to the standard "Pictures Folder", I have looked after Console logs and can't find anything.  
Are you sure it's working on Big Sur ?
Houdah Software
There indeed is a problem. Since macOS Big Sur refuses to run, it does not report Aperture as installed even when it is. Thus HoudahGeo's check for Aperture's presence fails.

Please try this new HoudahGeo beta. When macOS reports that Aperture is not installed, the beta checks the Application folder for Aperture.app. The beta also add support for Retroactive.

Since you have move the Aperture library, you should also update the com.apple.iApps.plist preferences file.
Member #1312 original poster
I tried as soon as you posted and had to wait until this evening  to try to debug it.
It still does not  work.

The com.apple.iApps.plist references :
file://localhost/Users/myname/Photos/Aperture%20Library.aplibrary/ApertureData.xml

... the path is correct but there are no ApertureData.xml file in the folder. 
Nor are there any in my old mac where the library comes from.
And neither seems to be any such file in the other Aperture subfolders. 

So maybe is this the root of the problem ?
Houdah Software
The ApertureData.xml is needed. It is created by Aperture when you enable preview sharing in Aperture > Preferences > Previews > Share XML with other application. This allows other applications, like HoudahSpot, to access previews in the Aperture library.

The problem now, of course, is that you need to run Aperture not only to change that setting, but also for it to create the previews and the XML file.

You may want to try the Retroactive tool to run Aperture on Big Sur.
You could also try to have Aperture create the XML on your old Mac and then copy the updated library over to the new Mac.

What is your goal here?
Do you plan to continue to use Aperture?
Do you want to use HoudahGeo to copy Aperture metadata to original image files?
Member #1312 original poster
Yes !!!
Problem solved. Thanks.

I want to migrate to Capture One and I didn't want to use a patched Aperture to write the GPS data in the original Raw file. Also, I would like to add IPTC Reverse geocoding, as C1 does not offer searching by map, and I'm not quite sure what is inside my Aperture database about that. Also I want to test the process to use Houdah Geo to write in the raw file, as I feel that would make the pictures more easily attached to the localization information. 

For the migration, I am still pondering wether to use C1 built-in importer, which is pretty basic, or use Avalanche. but they are late in their development schedule. So I 'm not completely set on how I will handle the geolocalised data.
I do not intend to use aperture anymore once the migration done.
Member #1321
Had a similar problem.The Beta version solved the issue straight out of the box. Trust the fix will be carried through.