Houdah Software Forum Archive

Lightroom Workflow

Member #333
This is likely to have been covered already but I use Adobe Lightroom 2.x. I'm trying to figure out the best workflow to use with HoudahGeo to geotag CR2 raw images. I have observations of Houdah and some questions as well.

Things I notice about how Houdah geotags...

* It doesn't modify the date/time on the photo it stores the metadata in containing the geotagged data... this is good.

* It doesn't auto-reverse lookup the location based on the gps coordinates automatically... this is NOT good. I had to later go back and cycle through the process again. Why isn't this done for you?  Isn't that why we are geotagging in the first place??

* If I have imported the photos into LR already, i get conflicts in Metadata status. If HoudahGeo can write to CR2 images without writing to .xmp sidecar files, they why can't HG write to the catalog without requiring a Save first of the LR pre-existing metadata?... basically do a "merge" of the geotag data with what's there.  I don't want to clutter up my drive with .xmp files.  I prefer to keep my metadata changes, etc in the LR catalog (database). Instead LR mandates I write (Save) the existing metadata first (which writes .xmp sidecar files for each photo) then Read in the metadata stored on the CR2 file just geotagged by HG. This seems wierd... LR writes metadata to .xmp file, but HG reads geotagged metadata from the original CR2 file "next door".

* HG's export of the metadata offers a Copy option so I figured I'd plug my card from the camera containing my new photos to tag into the card reader and drag them directly into HG. That works fine.  I then run through the geotag process. Then when I export metadata it provides options, including the copy. It then shows progress bar exporting, then pops up a Save dialog if I checked the Copy option. Why doesn't HG indicate on this dialog that it's wanting me to locate where to save the freshly geotagged files? I mention this because the File > Save is not about saving metadata to photo files but about saving the HG "project" set. It too doesn't say what it's saving.  Houdah... please make the menu item read File > Save Project. Now back to my workflow... this Copy option dialog let's me save to my final location. But when I go to import that folder into LR it only gives one option (if I don't want to make more copies) and that is to Add photos to catalog without a copy or move. But this negates the option to apply my custom filenaming convention.  So I realized I should instead use the HG Copy option and save to a "temp" folder, then use the Move option on import into LR. This does allow renaming. It appears it will also allow me to specify placement based on date that I like to use... 2009/July/17/photo1.cr2, etc.

* For all the photos already imported into LR I'm not sure what the best flow is. It appears I have no choice but to save out .xmp sidecar files for all of them since I've applied copywrite metadata and keywords and development adjustments to most.  If I do that, then apply geotagging to these photos, HG will export it to the .xmp file won't it?  Now when I Read the new metadata in LR, the metadata will all be merged from the .xmp file.  At this point can I delete in the Finder all those .xmp files since the metadata is now in the LR catalog?  Basically I'm viewing the.xmp files as temp vehicles for merging the metadata from LR and HG.  Will this work?

I await your comments, suggestions and answers to any of these questions.
Houdah Software
Hi!

Reverse geocoding is not automatic as, unlike the other operations, it requires an Internet connection. Those users who like to use reverse geocoding, do indeed quite frequently request for it to be triggered automatically. I will have to think up a good solution for a future version of HoudahGeo.

To HoudahGeo, XMP files take precedence over the actual image files. I.e. if at the time you add an image to the project, the XMP file exists, HoudahGeo will read metadata from the XMP file. Similarly if during EXIF/XMP export a XMP sidecar is found, metadata is written to the sidecar and the image file is left untouched.

Best,

Pierre Bernard

Houdah Software s.à r.l.

Member #333 original poster
Thanks Pierre
Is it possible for HG to merge the geotag metadata with LR metadata within the LR catalog? I don't like to use/have .xmp files unless I'm wanting to export the photo for PS or Bridge to use... which is not often in these days of LR.
If the catalog has the data why does LR think a .xmp file is needed for the merge?
Houdah Software
Hi!

HoudahGeo has no option to write to the Lightroom catalog. HoudahGeo may write either to the image file or the XMP sidecar.

I believe Lightroom prefers using XMP sidecars. I guess your workflow of having Lightroom create the sidecar and remove it again once it has gotten geotags from HoudahGeo sounds quite resaonable.

BTW, I would prefer having Lightroom store the metadata in sidecars rather than in the database. It is then easier to access for third party tools. And it will stay around in a standardized format even if you move away from Lightroom.

Best,

Pierre Bernard

Houdah Software s.à r.l.

Member #333 original poster
I'm totally fine with sidecar files for portability. However 95% of my day to day use of photos is in LR until I am ready to upload photos to online servers, then I export them out of LR to JPG files.  But you are right, if I need to port photos to another app, then making the sidecar files is ok with me. I'm just looking for a way to sync geotag data with other metadata without having to use .xmp files.

Thanks for answering my question on HG writing metadata to photos.  Do you advise for/against opening raw images from card reader into HG for geotagging, then exporting with Copy option enabled? I'm uncomfortable writing geotagged data back to the memory card, prefer to only add additional new data to photos that are copies.

Why does HG do the export first (shows progress bar) THEN pops up file save when the Copy option is enabled?  It seems that the Save As copies should appear first, the show progress of exporting to the files being written out. Maybe I don't understand what HG is doing.

Can you address my suggestion for the Save dialog offering more explicit description of what you are saving in light of the File > Save.  As a HG newbie I was confused when I realized one save is for the project and the other is a save for the photo export. I'd encourage you to use Save Project in the File menu and on export call it "Export photos to this directory:" above the browse location (or something like that.)
Houdah Software
Hi!

I agree on your assessment that the menu item for saving the project should be renamed. Also the save panel on creating copies should have a message.

Importing images from the card using HoudahGeo by having it write out copies is a good idea. This way you also keep the originals on the card untouched and available as a backup until you are sure all images safely made it into Lightroom.

Not all memory cards can be directly accessed as file systems. For those cards that cannot be accessed by HoudahGeo, I would suggest using Apple's Image Capture to copy the images to your hard drive. There you may tag them in place without creating copies. Again, erase your memory card only once the images made it safely into your image library.

BTW, the "copy" option on HoudahGeo is enabled by default for the very purpose of discouraging users from modifying images while they still reside on the memory card.

Best,

Pierre Bernard

Houdah Software s.à r.l.

Member #333 original poster
> Also the save panel on creating copies should have a message.

I think calling it the same as what the navigation button calls it (Export) would help differentiate the two. In addition, I'd suggest that the default folder name you pre-fill in the form "HoudahGeo" should suggest it will contain exported photos so...
HoudahGeo Exported
or
HoudahGeo Geotagged

The reason I suggest this is, the first couple times I exported, I thought that since I had selected (left selected) the make copies option, and that it asked for the folder AFTER the export progress bar, that it was asking for where to save the Original photos... i.e. I thought it wrote to the photos where they were but then wrote the originals to the folder in question. Basically I thought it was asking where to write the "backup" photos that were still untouched. After experimenting I found this wasn't the case. This alters the scenario impacting not only what I named the folder but where I placed it. Clarifying the experience from the get go reduces confusion and frustration when users assume what is going on (because it's not explicitely stated in the UI) and later find out they are wrong. This is why I feel the folder name pre-fill or the descriptive text around it in the dialog box should indicate clearly what is going on at that moment.

> BTW, the "copy" option on HoudahGeo is enabled by default

Yes, this is a good feature, IMHO.