Houdah Software Forum Archive

Somehow lost with the Compare feature

Member #1363
Hello,

I am absolutely thrilled with the idea of the software. I am particularly taken with the Compare function. I currently have a Creative Cloud subscription to access Lightroom Classic just to be able to use its comparison feature. I had hoped that Photos Workbench would allow me to turn my back on Adobe. Unfortunately, Photos Workbench does not currently do this. I have to say in all honesty that the implementation in its current form takes a lot of getting used to and is not intuitive for me. I'm downright at a loss to select a desired image, even though I've read the help beforehand. I find it hard to describe, but I am feel lost and don't even know how to finally mark the desired image. I would have thought that I could just click on the heart at the end, but that didn't work. Also, I can neither hide (not sure if this was possible) nor delete the unselected pictures. And it would be helpful if I could assign "hearts" not only on the left side. I am missing a magnifying glass (it seems to zoom in on a completely random position) and a way back out of the Compare screen. Somehow it all works more or less, but it is not immediately obvious to me as a user. 

Kind regards
Houdah Software
Thank you for the feedback. I will check out the comparison feature in LIghtroom.

The compare mode in Photos Workbench is mostly inspired by the comparison feature in Apple Aperture.

Photos Workbench works with the Photos library. This unfortunately lacks a good way to represent a "stack" of photos with the pick at the top. Thus Photos Workbench leaves it up to you to decide how you want to mark your picks. It does hint at using the "heart" / "favorite" by giving you that option below the picked image. Here are a few other ideas:
  • When you exit Compare mode, the pick (best image) remains selected. You could add that to a special album
  • You can decide to use the 5-star rating for images that came out at the top
  • The keyword controls are available in Compare mode. Tag the pick with "Best" and use a Smart Album in Photos to view only these photos. Sidenote: Photos Workbench cannot create Smart Albums

Below one of the photos in Compare mode you can see a selection indicator. A line between the star rating and the hear or checkmark button. The Info/Inspector on the right-hand side as well as the Keywords palette apply to the image that has the indicator. I.e. when the candidate photo has the selection indicator, you can use the Info pane to add a "heart" to that photo. Click the selection indicator to toggle the selection.

I hope this clarifies things. Things however should be obvious/intuitive. Compare mode needs improvements here. Please let me know if the above leaves questions open or if you see room for improvement.

I have noted the suggestion for the magnifying glass. Love the idea. Not sure it can make it into 1.0.
Member #1363 original poster
Hello,

thank you very much for your detailed answer! I am really looking forward to the final release. 

In the meantime I have found out many of the things through trial and error, but above all I wanted to report back that I do not find the operation really intuitive in parts. I was also unsure in some cases what could be bugs and what I felt was only a problem in the user interface. For example, the "heart" icon in the left field only works sporadically and I was unsure whether you can only give "likes" via the right sidebar. Also, the indicator for the active image is quite subtle and you first have to understand that the right bar refers to the image with the small "line". To make matters worse, the click target for the inactive window is very difficult to find / hit. This can certainly be solved more elegantly / more easily - if necessary, simply by a larger area that sets the image as active.

I have noted a few more points, some of which have already been mentioned. For the sake of completeness, I will list them again:

#### Main View

Keywords and Locations are toggles for info panes but GPX Track and Change Titles open other windows not directly connected to the given view - a little bit irritating at first

### Single Mode

sometimes left / right arrow do not go to next pictures

### List Mode

changing star ratings multiple times on the same image leads to a disappearing list

### Compare Mode

* space toggles sidebar not active photo (for detail screen)
* very hard to find and press the click target for active photo indicator
* zoom only possible via double click on left photo
* does not zoom to the area doube clicked into
* heart icon for left panel sometimes not selectable
* missing way to delete / hide pictures
* no way to remove star rating via mouse

### Feature Requests ;-)

„Go to selected picture in Apple Photos“ (where you can do more / other things then)
Houdah Software
Wow. Thank you!

The GPX tracks and bulk rename features need to be separate windows - modal sheets - as these are multi-step batch operations: you configure options, and changes are applied to several images. Later you may undo all changes in one command-Z step.

I do not understand "space toggles sidebar not active photo (for detail screen)"

Zoom in compare mode has several bugs. It works only on the left photo. Zoom using the pinch gesture works correctly. Zoom using double click has up and down reversed. I.e. double-click top right and it zooms to the bottom right.

You can remove a photo from an album by pressing the delete/backspace key. Menu items and context menus will be added soon.

I love the feature request.
Member #1363 original poster
Hello again ;-)

The manual says "The current selection is marked by a bar below the photo. Click that bar or press the space key to switch the selection to the other photo". This only works - if at all - a few times. Pressing space bar several times in a row suddenly selects different options. At first the Sidebar button (upper left corner), right now the heart icon ... Might have something to do with the fact that I have "Move the focus to controls using keyboard navigation" option enabled under Keyboard / Shortcuts in the Settings.app (I am using a non ENG OS, therefore I have to guess the settings' names.)